Fingernails are small and they matter more than people expect. A nail stiffens the fingertip for pinch, and is one of the first things anyone notices about a hand. A nail that is split, ridged, grooved, hooked or lifted catches on clothing, collects dirt and can hurt. Most nail deformities come from an old injury to the nail bed, a cyst from the joint beneath, or a skin or nail disease. The first task is to find the cause, because many need no surgery. Where the cause is a cyst or a scar, nail revision surgery can give the nail a more normal and functional shape.
What is a nail deformity?
The nail plate is made by a strip of tissue under the skin fold at the base of the nail, the matrix. From there the plate grows forward over the nail bed, which adds a thin layer to its underside and keeps it stuck down. A nail grows about 3 mm a month, so it takes four to six months to replace itself.
A deformity happens when something changes the matrix or the bed. Damage to the matrix changes how the nail is made: a split, a missing section, or a nail that is thin or absent. Damage to the bed changes how the nail travels and sticks: ridges, grooves and a nail that lifts off. Pressure from beneath, from a cyst or a bone spur, produces a groove that follows the nail as it grows.
Symptoms
- A nail that catches on clothing, hair or bedding
- A ridge or groove along the nail, or a split that re-forms every time the nail grows
- Pain under or around the nail, especially when it lifts or snags
- Repeated infections at the nail fold, or a cyst beside the joint that leaks clear fluid
- Embarrassment about the look of the hand, which is a legitimate reason to seek advice
Causes and risk factors
Injury. The most common cause. A nail bed cut that was not repaired, or healed with a scar, from a door, a crush or a knife, sometimes decades ago. See our fingertip injury page.
Mucoid cyst. The joint closest to the fingernail, the DIP joint, is a common site for mild osteoarthritis to produce a cyst filled with clear joint fluid. A cyst close to the nail fold presses on the matrix and grooves the nail plate. Left untreated it can cause a permanent nail deformity, repeatedly drain joint fluid or cause infections.
Fingertip amputation, which leaves the nail unsupported so it hooks down over the tip.
Infection and skin disease. Chronic paronychia in people whose hands are often wet, fungal infection of the nail, psoriasis, eczema and lichen planus.
Lumps under the nail. A bone spur, a wart, a glomus tumour and, rarely, a melanoma.
How it is diagnosed
By examination of the nail, the fold and the fingertip, and usually an X-ray. The pattern tells us where the problem is: a split points to the matrix under the fold, a groove to the bed or to pressure from a cyst, a hook to missing bone. The X-ray shows osteoarthritis and bone spurs at the DIP joint, the source of a mucoid cyst, and any bony lump under the nail.
Where the nail is thickened or discoloured, clippings are sent for fungal culture. A dark streak in the nail, or a lump under it, may need a biopsy of the nail bed.
Non-surgical treatment
Treating the cause
Fungal nails are treated with antifungal medication and skin disease by a dermatologist. Chronic paronychia settles with keeping the hands dry and avoiding manicures and cuticle pushing. Nail biting and picking need to stop before any repair is considered.
Protecting the nail
A split or lifted nail catches less when it is kept short, filed smooth and covered with a plaster or a drop of nail glue at the split. This is not a cure, and for a mild deformity it is often enough.
Hand therapy
Where the fingertip is tender or the DIP joint is stiff, our hand therapists, on site, desensitise the tip and work on movement.
Surgery
Surgery is advised where the deformity is caused by something that can be removed, such as a cyst, a spur or a scar, where the nail is painful or repeatedly infected, or where it hooks or splits in a way that gets in the way of using the hand. The aim is a nail that is flatter, smoother, firmly attached and comfortable.
Mucoid cyst excision
The cyst is removed through a curved incision in the skin overlying the cyst and the DIP joint. Bony bumps at the origin of the cyst are removed too, because the cyst comes back if they are left. In most cases the raised skin is rotated slightly to allow the wound to be closed with small sutures, a local flap procedure. A tape bandage covers the wound under a soft finger dressing. It is a day surgery procedure using sedation and a local anaesthetic, and takes approximately 20 minutes. The groove grows out over the following months once the pressure is gone.
Nail bed revision
For a split or ridged nail from an old injury, the nail plate is removed, the scar in the matrix or bed is cut out and the healthy edges are repaired with fine dissolving sutures under magnification. Where the gap is too wide to close, the missing bed is replaced with a thin graft of nail bed taken from a toe. The nail plate or a foil splint goes back under the fold to shape the new nail. It is a day surgery procedure using sedation and a local anaesthetic, and takes 30 to 60 minutes.
Hook nail correction and nail removal
A hook nail is corrected by shortening the nail bed back to the bone that supports it and resurfacing the tip with a small local flap. Where a nail is painful, repeatedly infected and beyond repair, the nail and its matrix can be removed so that no nail grows back, which is a last resort.
Recovery, week by week
Indicative, based on mucoid cyst excision. Nail bed revision follows a similar path with a bulkier dressing for the first two weeks.
Day of surgery. Some of your fingers may feel numb or tingly for two to three days because of the local anaesthetic. You can use your fingers, including the operated one, for light tasks before you leave hospital.
Days 1 to 3. Keep the dressing clean and dry. On day 2 or 3 you can take the dressing off your finger, keeping the tape bandage on the skin intact.
Days 3 to 14. The tape bandage can get wet in the shower. Dab it dry afterwards and avoid swimming and bathing the finger. Use the hand lightly and avoid heavy tasks.
Two weeks. Your progress is reviewed by the doctor, hand therapist or practice nurse, and the skin sutures are removed. If needed, a new tape bandage goes on for another three to five days.
Two to six weeks. Wound healing takes two to three weeks. The area around the scar can stay tender, pink or swollen for four and sometimes six weeks. Moisturising and massage help.
Three to six months. The new nail has grown out from the fold to the tip. This is the earliest the final shape of the nail can be judged.
Driving and work. Most people are back to driving and to office and light work at four to five days. Light manual work generally follows at two to four weeks, and heavy work at four to six weeks.
Risks and complications
Nail surgery is routine and safe, and complications rarely occur. They can include:
Wound healing problems, infection, bleeding or bruising. Usually minor and settled with dressings or antibiotics.
Ongoing tenderness or swelling around the scar, or slower than expected recovery.
The nail deformity may not improve, or a deformity may develop after the surgery.
Recurrence of a mucoid cyst. In approximately 1 in 20 cases the DIP joint produces another cyst, which may require another procedure.
Ongoing arthritis pain or stiffness at the DIP joint, which the cyst operation does not treat. Where the joint itself is the main problem, see our DIP arthritis page.
When to be seen sooner
Contact us, or see your GP, if you have:
- A brown or black streak that has appeared in one nail, is widening or has spread onto the skin at the fold, which needs a biopsy to exclude melanoma and should not wait
- A lump under the nail that is lifting it, bleeding or painful
- A cyst at the fingertip that has become red, hot and swollen, or that keeps leaking fluid, because an infected mucoid cyst can track into the joint
- A nail that has lifted completely after an injury, which may mean a nail bed cut underneath
If you have had surgery with us and have questions or concerns afterwards, phone the rooms during office hours on (08) 7127 0365.
Frequently asked questions
Can a split nail be fixed?
Often improved, not always cured. A split comes from a scar in the matrix under the nail fold. Cutting the scar out and repairing or grafting the matrix gives a smoother nail in many cases, but the repair itself can scar. We will tell you honestly what we expect for your nail before you decide.
Should I have the cyst drained with a needle?
Draining a mucoid cyst with a needle gives temporary relief and it refills in most cases, because the connection to the joint is still there. Puncturing it also opens a path for infection into the joint, so please do not do it at home.
How long does a nail take to grow back?
About four to six months from the fold to the tip. A new nail often looks rough, ridged or lifted while it grows out. Judge the result when it has reached the fingertip, not before.
When can I drive and go back to work?
Driving and office work at four to five days. Light manual work at two to four weeks, heavy work at four to six weeks. There is no legislation covering surgery and driving, so the test is whether you can control the car safely. We will give you a realistic estimate for your job, and a certificate.
What does the surgery cost?
You receive a written quote after the consultation setting out the surgeon, anaesthetist and hospital fees, your Medicare rebate and your health fund's contribution, before anything is booked.
Do I need a referral?
Yes. A consultation with one of our surgeons needs a referral from your GP or another specialist, which also lets you claim the Medicare rebate. Hand therapy does not need a referral.
Written and clinically reviewed by Dr Paul van Minnen, MD, PhD, EBOPRAS, FRACS (Plast)
Last reviewed 8 November 2026